Portal latinoamericano de toxicología
Bengal’s methanol tragedy: Death toll rises to 143; over 350 still in hospital
15 December, 2011
Bootleg liquor kills 143 people in eastern India.By BIKAS DAS, Associated Press. December 15, 2011. Bootleg liquor containing toxic methanol killed 143 people and sickened dozens more who drank the cheap, illicit brew bought at small shops in eastern India, officials said Thursday. Police arrested 10 suspected bootleggers. Emergency medical teams rushed to the village outside Kolkata, and thousands of relatives, many of them wailing in grief, gathered outside the packed hospital. Inside, dead bodies lay on the floor covered in quilts, while the ill waited on staircases to be treated. Groups of men sat in the halls with saline drips running into their arms.
Abdul Gayen cried inconsolably for his son, Safiulla, a laborer who drank some of the liquor Monday night and then complained of lightheadedness. When Safiulla woke up the next morning, he fell and began frothing at the mouth, Gayen said. He died before his family could get him to the hospital.
"Safiulla was the lone bread earner in our family. I don’t know what will happen to us now," he said.
Illegal liquor operations flourish in the slums of urban India and among the rural poor who can’t afford the alcohol at state-sanctioned shops. The hooch, often mixed with cheap chemicals to increase potency and profit, causes illness and death sometimes — and occasionally mass carnage.
Many of the victims — day laborers, street hawkers, rickshaw drivers — had gathered along a road near a railway station after work to drink the illicit booze they bought for 10 rupees (20 cents) a half liter, less than a third the price of legal alcohol, district magistrate Naraya Swarup Nigam said.
They later began vomiting, suffering piercing headaches and frothing at the mouth, he said.
Angry villagers later ransacked booze shops around the village of Sangrampur, about 30 kilometers (20 miles) south of Kolkata, the city formerly known as Calcutta.
Police arrested 10 people in connection with making and distributing the methanol-tainted booze and demolished 10 illicit liquor dens in the area, said Luxmi Narayan Meena, district superintendent of police.
Arman Seikh, 23, rushed his brother-in-law to the hospital.
"He complained of burning chest and severe stomach pain last night," he told The Associated Press.
Police officials said the liquor was from an illegal distillery in the village of Mograhat that supplies 70 shops in the area. Police are searching for the kingpin of the operation, who has fled, they said.
Drinking alcohol contains ethanol, whereas highly toxic methanol — a clear liquid that can be used as fuel, solvent or antifreeze — can induce comas and cause blindness and is deadly in high doses.
Anwar Hassan Mullah brought six sickened people to a hospital, and all of them died, he told NDTV news channel. He blamed police for turning a blind eye to bootleggers who spike their alcohol to boost its kick.
"It’s a very sad thing that this has happened," Mullah said. "Why don’t the police stop this? I cannot understand. What connection do they have (to the bootleggers)?"
By Thursday evening, the death toll had skyrocketed to 143, said Surajit Kar Purkayaspha, a top West Bengal police official. About 100 people were being treated in hospitals, he said.
West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee ordered an inquiry into the deaths, called for a meeting of the state’s major political parties to address the problem and promised a crackdown.
"I want to take strong action against those manufacturing and selling illegal liquor," she said, according to Press Trust of India. "But this is a social problem also, and this has to be dealt with socially also along with action."
Despite religious and cultural taboos against drinking among Indians, 5 percent — roughly 60 million people — are alcoholics. Two-thirds of the alcohol consumed in the country is illegal homemade hooch or undocumented liquor smuggled in, according to The Lancet medical journal.
The state of Gujarat, where all liquor is banned, just approved a death penalty for making, transporting or selling spurious liquor that kills people. The strict measures were proposed after 157 people died from drinking a bad batch of liquor in the city of Ahmedabad in 2009. At least 180 people died in 2008 around the southern Indian city of Bangalore from a toxic batch of homemade liquor.
The mass casualties came just days after a hospital fire in Kolkata killed more than 90 people and led to the arrest of the facility’s directors for culpable homicide.
Illicit liquor is a hugely profitable industry across India, where bootleggers pay no taxes and sell enormous quantities of their product, said Johnson Edayaranmula, executive director of the Indian Alcohol Policy Alliance, an organization that fights alcohol-related problems.
The bootleggers, working in homes, hidden warehouses and even in forests, can turn 1 liter of genuine alcohol into 1,000 liters of bootlegged swill with chemicals and additives that usually cause no harm, but on occasion can lead to tragedy, he said.
Every week, one or two people across the country die from tainted liquor, he said. In 2009, at least 112 people died from a toxic brew in western India.
"People don’t know what they are drinking," he said. "It’s all easy money, big profits. No one is bothered by the health or social consequences."
The trade is allowed to flourish despite strict laws against spurious liquor because corrupt police, local officials and tax authorities all get a cut of the profits, he said.
"Many people are getting a share out of it, so who is going to take action against these people," he said.
Associated Press writer Manik Banerjee contributed to this report.
Read more: Hooch tragedy toll rises to 167.thehindubusinessline.com. December 16, 2011.The death toll in the spurious liquor tragedy that struck Sangrampur and adjoining villages in the Diamond Harbour subdivision of the State’s South 24 Parganas mounted to 167 on Friday with nearly 100 other persons fighting for their lives in hospitals.
The shadow of death has descended in the area since the tragedy that claimed its first victims on Wednesday. Ambulances kept ferrying the ill to the Diamond Harbour sub-divisional hospital even as rickshaws were carrying the bodies of the dead back to their homes in the opposite direction.
‘Tragic situation’
“The situation in the villages is very tragic. In some villages 40 -50 people have died, most of them earning members of the family,” said Md Giyasuddin Molla, MLA from Magrahat Paschim constituency.
Villagers ransacked the house of one of the kingpins of the hooch mafia, ‘Khora Badhsha’ at Magrahat, who they alleged had a brewery and of late also supplied liquor to several areas including Sangrampur from Charan and Magrahat areas.
While a few fresh arrests were made today, taking the number of those arrested after the incident to 12, all known bootleggers including ‘Khora Badshah’ remained elusive. An officer in charge of Excise department of Diamond Harbour range has been suspended for failing to conduct raids on illicit liquor dens in the area.
Collector’s report
Mr N.S. Nigam, the district magistrate, submitted a preliminary report to the State administration. It was learnt that the report mentioned the abnormally high level of methyl alcohol in the liquor samples heightening its toxicity.
But doctors who examined the patients at the hospital said that “symptoms of conventional poisoning was not evident among the patients” giving hints that there can be chemicals mixed with alcohol for heightened intoxication. Had those who had fallen ill after consumption of the illicit liquor brought in earlier, several lives could have been saved.
Locals admitted that initially there was a delay in admitting patients to the hospital. While the families of those taken ill feared police harassment, the other deterrent was the social stigma of drinking illicit liquor.
Interestingly, it was only after the State government announced compensation of Rs 2 lakh that many of the patients were brought to the hospital.
370 hospitalised
“So far about 370 patients have been admitted at the hospital of which 96 have been released,” Dr Sikha Adhikari, the Chief Medical Officer of Health of the district, South 24 Parganas, said. Fifty doctors were working round the clock at the hospital, which is woefully short of facilities.
The situation in city hospitals such as M R Bangur Hospital and Chittaranjan National Medical College was the same as the subdivision hospital at Diamond Harbour, with more patients pouring in and the authorities struggling to accommodate the rush. While there was improvement in the health parameters of some patients, there were cases of patients losing eyesight.
Watch video: Tainted alcohol kills scores in India
"Safiulla was the lone bread earner in our family. I don’t know what will happen to us now," he said.
Illegal liquor operations flourish in the slums of urban India and among the rural poor who can’t afford the alcohol at state-sanctioned shops. The hooch, often mixed with cheap chemicals to increase potency and profit, causes illness and death sometimes — and occasionally mass carnage.
Many of the victims — day laborers, street hawkers, rickshaw drivers — had gathered along a road near a railway station after work to drink the illicit booze they bought for 10 rupees (20 cents) a half liter, less than a third the price of legal alcohol, district magistrate Naraya Swarup Nigam said.
They later began vomiting, suffering piercing headaches and frothing at the mouth, he said.
Angry villagers later ransacked booze shops around the village of Sangrampur, about 30 kilometers (20 miles) south of Kolkata, the city formerly known as Calcutta.
Police arrested 10 people in connection with making and distributing the methanol-tainted booze and demolished 10 illicit liquor dens in the area, said Luxmi Narayan Meena, district superintendent of police.
Arman Seikh, 23, rushed his brother-in-law to the hospital.
"He complained of burning chest and severe stomach pain last night," he told The Associated Press.
Police officials said the liquor was from an illegal distillery in the village of Mograhat that supplies 70 shops in the area. Police are searching for the kingpin of the operation, who has fled, they said.
Drinking alcohol contains ethanol, whereas highly toxic methanol — a clear liquid that can be used as fuel, solvent or antifreeze — can induce comas and cause blindness and is deadly in high doses.
Anwar Hassan Mullah brought six sickened people to a hospital, and all of them died, he told NDTV news channel. He blamed police for turning a blind eye to bootleggers who spike their alcohol to boost its kick.
"It’s a very sad thing that this has happened," Mullah said. "Why don’t the police stop this? I cannot understand. What connection do they have (to the bootleggers)?"
By Thursday evening, the death toll had skyrocketed to 143, said Surajit Kar Purkayaspha, a top West Bengal police official. About 100 people were being treated in hospitals, he said.
West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee ordered an inquiry into the deaths, called for a meeting of the state’s major political parties to address the problem and promised a crackdown.
"I want to take strong action against those manufacturing and selling illegal liquor," she said, according to Press Trust of India. "But this is a social problem also, and this has to be dealt with socially also along with action."
Despite religious and cultural taboos against drinking among Indians, 5 percent — roughly 60 million people — are alcoholics. Two-thirds of the alcohol consumed in the country is illegal homemade hooch or undocumented liquor smuggled in, according to The Lancet medical journal.
The state of Gujarat, where all liquor is banned, just approved a death penalty for making, transporting or selling spurious liquor that kills people. The strict measures were proposed after 157 people died from drinking a bad batch of liquor in the city of Ahmedabad in 2009. At least 180 people died in 2008 around the southern Indian city of Bangalore from a toxic batch of homemade liquor.
The mass casualties came just days after a hospital fire in Kolkata killed more than 90 people and led to the arrest of the facility’s directors for culpable homicide.
Illicit liquor is a hugely profitable industry across India, where bootleggers pay no taxes and sell enormous quantities of their product, said Johnson Edayaranmula, executive director of the Indian Alcohol Policy Alliance, an organization that fights alcohol-related problems.
The bootleggers, working in homes, hidden warehouses and even in forests, can turn 1 liter of genuine alcohol into 1,000 liters of bootlegged swill with chemicals and additives that usually cause no harm, but on occasion can lead to tragedy, he said.
Every week, one or two people across the country die from tainted liquor, he said. In 2009, at least 112 people died from a toxic brew in western India.
"People don’t know what they are drinking," he said. "It’s all easy money, big profits. No one is bothered by the health or social consequences."
The trade is allowed to flourish despite strict laws against spurious liquor because corrupt police, local officials and tax authorities all get a cut of the profits, he said.
"Many people are getting a share out of it, so who is going to take action against these people," he said.
Associated Press writer Manik Banerjee contributed to this report.
Read more: Hooch tragedy toll rises to 167.thehindubusinessline.com. December 16, 2011.The death toll in the spurious liquor tragedy that struck Sangrampur and adjoining villages in the Diamond Harbour subdivision of the State’s South 24 Parganas mounted to 167 on Friday with nearly 100 other persons fighting for their lives in hospitals.
The shadow of death has descended in the area since the tragedy that claimed its first victims on Wednesday. Ambulances kept ferrying the ill to the Diamond Harbour sub-divisional hospital even as rickshaws were carrying the bodies of the dead back to their homes in the opposite direction.
‘Tragic situation’
“The situation in the villages is very tragic. In some villages 40 -50 people have died, most of them earning members of the family,” said Md Giyasuddin Molla, MLA from Magrahat Paschim constituency.
Villagers ransacked the house of one of the kingpins of the hooch mafia, ‘Khora Badhsha’ at Magrahat, who they alleged had a brewery and of late also supplied liquor to several areas including Sangrampur from Charan and Magrahat areas.
While a few fresh arrests were made today, taking the number of those arrested after the incident to 12, all known bootleggers including ‘Khora Badshah’ remained elusive. An officer in charge of Excise department of Diamond Harbour range has been suspended for failing to conduct raids on illicit liquor dens in the area.
Collector’s report
Mr N.S. Nigam, the district magistrate, submitted a preliminary report to the State administration. It was learnt that the report mentioned the abnormally high level of methyl alcohol in the liquor samples heightening its toxicity.
But doctors who examined the patients at the hospital said that “symptoms of conventional poisoning was not evident among the patients” giving hints that there can be chemicals mixed with alcohol for heightened intoxication. Had those who had fallen ill after consumption of the illicit liquor brought in earlier, several lives could have been saved.
Locals admitted that initially there was a delay in admitting patients to the hospital. While the families of those taken ill feared police harassment, the other deterrent was the social stigma of drinking illicit liquor.
Interestingly, it was only after the State government announced compensation of Rs 2 lakh that many of the patients were brought to the hospital.
370 hospitalised
“So far about 370 patients have been admitted at the hospital of which 96 have been released,” Dr Sikha Adhikari, the Chief Medical Officer of Health of the district, South 24 Parganas, said. Fifty doctors were working round the clock at the hospital, which is woefully short of facilities.
The situation in city hospitals such as M R Bangur Hospital and Chittaranjan National Medical College was the same as the subdivision hospital at Diamond Harbour, with more patients pouring in and the authorities struggling to accommodate the rush. While there was improvement in the health parameters of some patients, there were cases of patients losing eyesight.
Watch video: Tainted alcohol kills scores in India